TJ Larkin

Newsletter growth

What survey questions should a newsroom ask new newsletter subscribers?

Short answer

Only ask what you'll act on. For a newsroom that usually means zip code first, business owner, donate yes, maybe or no, interest in events, and maybe a second newsletter or daily digest option. Four or five questions is plenty. Skip 'what should we cover' unless you'll actually change coverage based on it.

Every question in a newsroom's signup survey should have a job. If there's no ad strategy, no donor strategy and nothing specific you're pushing, what's the point of asking it?

"Each question should have a goal: what are you going to do with that information?"

Which questions earn their spot?

QuestionWhat you do with it
Zip code (first)Donor prospecting and wealth screening, plus local targeting
Do you own or run a local business?Advertiser outreach and your media kit
Would you like to donate? Yes, maybe, noDonor follow-up, harder on "maybe"
Interested in events? Yes, maybe, noEvent invites to a raised-hand segment
Want our other newsletter or a daily digest?One-click add to a second list

Four or five questions is about right for most newsrooms. One newsroom I worked with landed on events interest, a donation call-out, a second-newsletter option and a daily digest choice, after we cut everything they wouldn't use.

Why zip code instead of city?

Zip code helps with wealth screening for donors. A newsroom raising money gets more from zip.

I worried that a required, typed zip code as question one would hurt completion. People usually want to move fast. A public nonprofit newsroom ran it anyway and about 75% to 80% of new subscribers went all the way through.

How should you use the donation answer?

Treat "maybe" as a warm lead. Hit the people who said maybe harder later than the people who said no. One nonprofit newsroom client had 77 people pick "remind me later" on the donation question within about eight or nine days of launch. That's a ready-made follow-up list.

If you don't have a paid plan, the donation is really the main thing you want from people, so the page after the survey can send them straight to it.

How should you use the events answer?

Keep it simple: yes, maybe, no. Don't overcomplicate it with "what kind of events." When you host something, email the yes and maybe groups about it, and hit them far harder than everyone else. You can email that raised-hand segment twice as much.

Is the business-owner question worth it if most people say no?

Yes. Even the people who say no just saw a line telling them you sell advertising. It works as an ad for your ads.

"Even if they don't say yes, you're still putting it in their face that you can advertise with us."

What about questions you might use later?

Here's the counterweight. If you can see a plausible future use, collect it now, because you can never go back and catch people at the moment they signed up. I didn't ask the business-owner question until way late, and I can't recover that data for my older subscribers.

The test is the same either way: how would segmenting by this answer give you value? A question like "what topics should we cover" usually fails it, because you're probably not going to change your coverage based on the answers.

Answered by TJ Larkin. From client and partner calls in 2025 and 2026. Last updated .

Related answers

TJ Larkin / Answers / Newsletter growth